Reviews
There are so many incredible books available at the moment that it is impossible to read them all, no matter how hard I try! Here are my thoughts about some of the books I have read and how I think they could be used in school as well as Q and A sessions with authors and illustrators.
Thunder City
Tamzin Pook does battle with Revenants in Margate’s Amusement Arcade where she is the star fighter, having survived forty-nine fights. Others are not so lucky.
When a brutal coup takes place in the wheeled city of Thorbury, Miss Torpenhow, a teacher from that city, seeks Tamzin’s help, breaking her out of the Arcade. Events progress at a rapid pace and Tamzin finds herself part of an ill-matched group, banded together in their desire to free Thorbury- and find a new life.
No poor attempt at a summary could ever do justice to the perfectly paced, tightly plotted and absolutely absorbing experience which reading a Moral Engines book offers. It was an absolute joy to return to this world!
Set about a hundred years before the setting of the first book, ‘Thunder City’ is as imaginative and richly drawn as the other stories. It is easy to read it as a stand alone story, but for anyone who has read the other books, it is fascinating to see this world following the rules of Municipal Darwinism yet before the more ruthless town-eat-town era to come.
Tamzin is a wonderful character. Thrown into the brutal world of the Amusement Arcade, she has developed her own survival strategies, trying hard not to form attachments. However, with her freedom from this life, she learns she can trust and be trusted, forming new bonds, showing her to be a courageous and loyal friend. The other characters who become part of her group are equally well developed and believable (Miss Torpenhow is just brilliant!) and I am convinced that Philip Reeve will not be heartless enough to deprive the world of more stories leading from this wonderful beginning!
Thunder City
Philip Reeve
Scholastic ISBN: 978-0702335471
North and the Only One
Since she woke up, Rose can’t remember anything- except her puppy, North. Mother is patient and helpful, carefully filling in the blanks, but Rose can’t quite shake off the feeling that something isn’t right. She isn’t allowed to draw back the curtains and can only venture into the garden early in the morning or at sunset, wearing a large-brimmed hat. She has strange dreams which Mother can’t -or won’t explain- and waking from one of these leads her to a discovery which frightens her into fleeing from the house. Once outside, however, it quickly becomes clear that she is different to those around her…
‘North and the Only One’ hits the high standard expected from a Vashti Hardy novel whilst managing to be different to her other books! It is a thoroughly engaging read, offering much to reflect upon and discuss.
As humans have died out ‘due to their own stupidity’ humanoid robots have replaced them, leaving Rose feeling alienated and completely alone, clinging to North, her companion and the only thing which she feels is familiar to her. When she escapes from her mother, Rose finds herself in the city where everything seems perfect- and yet its inhabitants are quick to judge, criticise difference and wish to be rid of anything which doesn’t fit their idea of ‘normal’. Her humanity makes her stand out, allowing readers to reflect on the importance of individuality!
The book focuses on Rose’s journey- literal and metaphorical- to find out who she really is, and we see the world through her eyes as she encounters things for the first time, reflecting on and sometimes questioning what she discovers and the book would make an excellent guided reading text, offering as it does so much to explore and discuss.
An excellent, imaginative adventure, ‘North and the Only One’ is a moving, wise tale with much to recommend it.
‘We’re all the same. We’re all made of stories.’
North and the Only One
Vashti Hardy
Scholastic ISBN: 978-0702312274
You can read my review of ‘Serpent in the Sands’ here.
I am Wolf
Coll is Wolf.
He lives with his clan on a Construct, a huge technological “creature” driven by the clan’s combined willpower. Together they roam their world, fighting other clans and absorbing them into their own.
But when a new and dangerous Construct attacks them, Coll is thrown clear from Wolf and left behind. Now he must survive life on ground and get back to his clan. He is helped by Rieka, a “Tock” who makes the Constructs work. She promises Coll a way to return, but can she be trusted? And what is she really trying to do…?
When Coll uncovers the truth, it destroys everything he thought he knew about his clan, the world they live in, and even himself. In a world full of danger, and suddenly without meaning, can he find a way back?
(Book blurb)
This is an excellent adventure which would make an excellent class story. There are echoes of ‘Mortal Engines’ at first glance; however, this is a very original and compelling story.
Coll is a great character. Being part of Wolf means that different is bad, and due to his prosthetic arm and leg, Col stands out as being different. With his mother being Alpha, he is constantly seeking to prove that he deserves his place on the Construct and is not there simply because of their relationship. When he becomes stranded from his clan, he has to learn to trust others, to accept advice and to value himself as an individual, capable of flourishing with a new pack, no longer feeling the need to constantly prove himself. Impatient and, at times, impulsive and bad-tempered, he also shows surprising moments of kindness, making him a very relatable, flawed and engaging character. His relationships with the other characters who become part of his new crew are also drawn with great skill and individuality- Fillan is my favourite- but he, Rieka and Brann are all well developed, offering plenty to reflect upon and discuss, showing how unlikely friendships can develop and opposites can attract and work well as a team!
The action is constant, creating a pacey, exciting adventure, sure to engage and inspire the most reluctant reader! It is a world with so much more to explore, making it a huge relief to realise that it is the first of a trilogy with ‘I am Raven’ coming soon!
I am Wolf Alastair Chisholm
Nosy Crow ISBN: 978-1839945311
You can read my review of ‘Orion Lost’ here, ‘The Consequence Girl’ here and ‘Dragon Storm’ here.
These Stolen Lives
Six years ago, Mora survived the Skøl invasion, an event which destroyed her family, stole the land and means that she must pay for the right to live. As a ‘repayer’, someone who has lived life without paying, she owes the Skøl a debt and her life is no longer her own, but at least she wasn’t culled like so many others- a fate still facing anyone who can’t pay. When she learns that Zako, a twelve-year-old boy she has known all his life, has tried to kill his owner, the magistrate, Valour Venor, soon to be governor of the North Western Counties, Mora knows she has to act. However, in freeing Zako and smuggling him to tenuous safety, Mora and her friend, Kit, find themselves drawn deep into a perilous and dark mystery.
‘These Stolen Lives’ is an incredibly powerful, hard-hitting novel which mingles raw events of past invasions and occupations with imagined details of a fantasy world. The brutality of the Skøl and the law-enforcing Branders, the constant racism, inequality and fear in which the indigenous peoples suffer daily are so vividly described that the story is not an easy read, but one which challenges and forces the reader to reflect and empathise.
And yet, through all the hardship, moments of joy, of kindness and of love shine through. The kindness and courage of the Scarlets who agree to shelter Zako make a stark contrast to the brutality and ignorance of Venor; the blossoming feelings between Mora and Kit is worlds away from the threat of sexual assault. The importance of cultural heritage and the powerful identity this forges is clearly shown as the oppressors try to destroy and the oppressed remember.
Against this chilling background, an extremely tense and compelling mystery unfolds, taking the reader to the very edge and then allowing them to relax for a moment before dealing a crushing blow at the end. There must be a sequel coming…
These Stolen Lives
Sharada Keats
Scholastic ISBN: 978-0702325120
You Could Be So Pretty
Beauty comes at a price. And girls must pay.
Belle Gentle follows the rules of The Doctrine to the letter and is so close to ‘Having It All’. The Doctrine helps girls navigate the world now the Bad Times are over by offering guidelines for how to behave. She’s the prettiest Pretty in school, A Chosen One in her spare time, and she’s about to win The Ceremony, making her family proud.
Joni Miller is an Objectionable. Although she is despised by others for rejecting the Doctrine, this is her Choice. She is determined to win the Scholarship into the Education so she can change things- but her biggest rival is perfect Belle.
Being far older than the target audience for this book, I found it deeply disturbing and sad- and yet, as I closed it, I was filled with the hope that for those reading it, it will provoke thought and discussions. The story offers a blistering look at a dystopian ‘future’ where the expectations on girls to be effortlessly perfect, whilst bearing all the responsibility for the reactions which they might ‘incite’ from men, are overwhelming. This is a society where violence against women is normalised, with degrading, dehumanising Smut (pornography) a part of every day life and where any girl who doesn’t find this arousing, fun and healthy is a Frigid. And yet, much of this sounds chillingly familiar, reflecting the everyday realities faced by many girls today.
And this is where Holly Bourne skilfully turns this into more than just another dystopian tale. The society she portrays in intensely suffocating with something on almost every page which causes the reader to feel both intensely uncomfortable and furious…and provoke reflection. Women are told that they have won equality, that they have choice, but ‘choice means nothing if you feel you have no other option than to choose what everyone chooses…if there are significant consequences for not following the established path.’ Powerful stuff.
The other strength of this story is in the characterisation. Joni and Belle are girls you come to care about. The novel opens with glimpses of their past which put them each on the path they have taken in life, instantly creating empathy. Belle is particularly fascinating as she finds herself questioning- and seeking to justify- things which make her intensely uncomfortable. Being an ‘Invisible’, my heart ached for both these girls - and all the women in the story- and for those in real life whose experience is similar.
A note at the beginning of the book warns the story might be triggering, but Holly Bourne should be commended for writing this book. For me, its importance is on a par with ‘Asking for It’ by Louise O’Neal- and that’s saying something.
Clever and compelling, startling and stirring, this is a must read.
You Could Be So Pretty Holly Bourne
Usborne ISBN: 978-1474966832
Electric Life
Alara lives a ‘perfect’ life in Estrella where everything is tightly controlled and it is mandatory to carry a ‘Flip’ (Fully Linked Information Platform) so everyone is connected. Feelings of boredom and being ‘dulled’ are frowned upon yet Alara often feels disconnected. The skyscraper city is built on the ruins of the old city, now known as London Under, and Alara finds herself selected to go on a secret mission to gather vital intelligence about a world completely different to her own. But what she discovers makes her start to question everything she has known…
I have said it before, but have to say it again- Rachel Delahaye is an outstanding writer who really knows how to create believable worlds and compelling characters, immersing the reader completely in the story. ‘Electric Life’ is a one-sitting read- it is impossible to put down once started.
As with ‘Day of the Whale’, another of Rachel’s books, the story is both a thoroughly good read and offers plenty to think about. As the story unfolds, it becomes clear that not everything is as it seems in the perfect world of Estrella, posing questions about what citizens of the ‘Star City’ might be sacrificing for their idyllic lifestyle. Everyone seems to live their lives through and around their screens which provide entertainment and constantly monitor their health and safety. They are happy to accept the parameters and rules which keep them safe… there are so many questions to be asked here and Alara’s experiences certainly make the reader think about
The story is fast-paced and full of action, building a frighteningly believable version of the future. Alara is a very likeable character- standing out against the stereotypical versions of her peers, not quite fitting in, longing for different. Readers may well recognise her clumsy attempts to ‘find’ friends and be ‘normal’ and like her all the more for ultimately coming to be herself. As she has experiences we take for granted for the first time- feeling pain, sharing human contact, tasting real food, the wild joy of a party night out- you can feel her coming alive and responding to each new sensation.
There is so much more I could say, but for fear of spoiling this brilliant book for other readers, I will finish by saying- it’s fab. Make sure you read it!
Electric Life Rachel Delahaye
Troika ISBN: 978-1912745326
You can read my review of ‘Day of the Whale’ here.